Read on: My website
Read time: 2 Minutes
AI is not going to ruin your company by writing a few bad emails or a couple of really cool, eye-catching, fancy charts.
On the surface, everything will look great. Cleaner decks. Faster memos. Slicker analysis.
But underneath, the muscles that actually win markets, build judgment, develop creativity, shape character, define real leadership, negotiate, build trust internally and externally with customers, will be shrinking from lack of use.
If you are not careful and rely too heavily on what AI can do (and deliver), AI can impact your overall effectiveness on you and your company.
It will make it more generic, more fragile, and easier to beat, all while you are staring at charts that say productivity is up.
Was this newsletter forwarded to you?
It is going to ruin your company by slowly killing the skills, the trust, and the relationships that made you competitive in the first place.
Not overnight.
Quietly.
And you might not know it until it hits you in the face. Hard. When you lose a contract or a policy goes sideways, or something else negatively impacts you and your business.
All because there was an over-reliance on AI, instead of on human growth.
While the dashboards look great, everyone brags about automation. Let’s make sure you don’t run into that wall.
Let’s dance.
Smart starts here.
You don’t have to read everything — just the right thing. 1440’s daily newsletter distills the day’s biggest stories from 100+ sources into one quick, 5-minute read. It’s the fastest way to stay sharp, sound informed, and actually understand what’s happening in the world. Join 4.5 million readers who start their day the smart way.
The Dangers of Taking Easy Street
The more fluent AI becomes, the more your people will stop wrestling with problems themselves.
That is the trap.
You roll out a new assistant. It drafts clean analyses. It summarizes reports. It gives you structured options. It sounds confident. It looks competent. So your team starts leaning on it.
First for rough drafts. Then for first drafts. Then, for the thinking behind the draft.
On the surface, everything looks better. Fewer blank pages. Faster turnaround. Neater documents. Ah…I’ve saved time, you might think.
Underneath, something important is breaking. The reps that used to build judgment are being handed to a system that cannot build judgment at all.
Imagine a director who used to take a messy situation, sketch three options, argue through trade-offs with their VP, and then make a call.
Now they drop the situation into an AI, copy the suggested path, and move on. It saves time. It also skips the struggle that builds pattern recognition and discernment.
I have so many good (and not so good) memories of debating with my coworkers about projects, clients, competition, or how to get us out of a sticky situation.
It wasn’t just learning from others in my field; I would engage with leadership, government affairs, technical experts, engineers, outside counsel, the list goes on. Those who had more years in the industry than they would want to even admit to.
It built character.
It built negotiation skills.
It built camaraderie.
It built engagement. Understanding for others. Curiousity.
So what happens when you take that all away and rely on a computer?
Isolation.
Multiply that across a few hundred people and a few years. You get an organization that looks smarter on paper and is actually softer in reality. More automated, less adaptive. More data-driven, less people-driven.
If you do not actively fight this, it will not be a one-off mistake. It will be your new operating system.
Want to check out some of my other articles? Check them out here:
The Key…in Key Account Management Transitions
How to Build an Interactive Intelligence Dashboard in Claude
Breaking
The skills that make you and your company hard to compete with are not sitting in a single playbook. They live in how people learn, argue, and decide together over time.
Things like:
-
Judging messy situations when the data is incomplete.
-
Seeing second and third-order effects across functions.
-
Negotiating in the heat of the moment. Right then, in front of an audience, a decision needs to be made
-
Knowing when a decision is not just financial but ethical.
-
Looking at a problem through the lens of your specific strategy, not some generic best practice.
Those skills do not develop automatically. They only grow through use.
Right now, a lot of that development happens through actual human interaction. A junior sits in on crisis calls. An analyst gets grilled in a review. A manager watches how a senior leader handles a no-win trade-off. That is how tacit knowledge moves. It is slow. It is uncomfortable. It is what creates edge.
Now imagine you swap those reps for AI.
The junior manager does not call their director. They ask the model what to say. The analyst does not argue through the assumptions. They paste them into a chatbot and pull out a cleaned-up version. The cross-functional team does not battle it out in a room. They push the issue into a tool and accept the top-ranked suggestion.
On paper, everyone is more productive. In reality, your pipeline for real expertise is drying up. You are still hiring smart people.
You are just not giving them the conditions to become sharp operators.
If you want to stay competitive, you have to name the human capabilities you cannot afford to lose.
Write them down.
Judgment under uncertainty. Systems thinking. Ethical escalation. Interpretive reasoning. Thrives in chaos. Whatever might fit you best.
Then design AI usage so people still have to exercise those muscles instead of skipping leg day forever.
Culture is King
Your organization is not just a stack of workflows. It is a social system built on trust, shared memories, goals, objectives, and a sense of how we do things here.
Two leaders hashing out a disagreement in front of their teams. A project review where people own mistakes out loud. A tough decision where someone says, “This is on me,” and everyone sees it.
These moments are often messy. They are also where culture is built.
AI threatens that fabric in two ways if you let it run on autopilot.
First, it displaces interaction. Instead of pulling a colleague into a conversation, people quietly ask their personal assistant. Instead of debating options, they take the top three from a model. Instead of working through conflict, they work around each other. You end up with more individualized, machine-mediated workflows and fewer shared experiences.
Would you ever do this to a customer?
Second, it muddies accountability. When a recommendation comes from “the system,” who owns the outcome? The manager? The model? The team? Over time, people start to wonder if leaders are actually deciding or just relaying what a tool said.
You are not a robot.
Trust erodes. Authority blurs. People become less sure who is responsible and why.
If that sounds abstract, here is the concrete version.
You are not just risking slower decisions. You are risking a culture where nobody feels fully responsible for anything important. That is how organizations crumble, not from one big scandal, but from a thousand small abdications.
Protect Ya Neck
You cannot bolt AI on and hope the important stuff survives. You have to decide, explicitly, what you are going to protect.
Start here.
Draw a Hard Line
Make one list where AI can help draft, format, and accelerate. Make another list where humans must own the first pass.
For example, let AI tidy up a report, but require that a human writes the actual recommendation and the reasoning behind it. If you cannot make those lists, you are already offloading too much.
Areas of Excellence
Pick a few places where you forbid AI as the starting point. Crisis response. Strategic memos. Go/No Go Decisions, Performance reviews. Deal strategy.
Require people to think for themselves first. Then let them use AI to stress test, refine, or challenge their thinking, not to replace it.
Protect the Interactions
Look at your calendar and your org chart. Identify the meetings, reviews, and rituals where people actually learn how decisions get made. Deal reviews. Design critiques. Incident postmortems. Cross-functional planning.
Do not let those become async AI threads. They should be more human, not less.
Make Accountability Explicitly Human
AI is a tool, not a decision maker. Leaders still own the call, explain the logic, and stand behind the outcome. When things go well, highlight the human judgment that made it happen. When things go badly, do not blame the model.
If people see you hiding behind AI, they will start doing the same.
Lead & Own It – Talk About What It Cannot Do
Most AI conversations focus on feature lists. Flip that. Remind your org regularly what AI will never handle for you. It cannot develop expertise through lived experience. It cannot feel the weight of a hard call. It cannot build trust, courage, or shared purpose. Those are your job.
AI can absolutely make your company faster. That is not the question.
The question is whether you use that speed to deepen your advantage or flatten it.
If you treat AI as a replacement for the thinking, learning, and human connection that made you hard to beat, you will get a short-term productivity bump and a long-term decline that will not show up on a dashboard until it is too late.
If you treat AI as a powerful assistant that supports, but never substitutes, the skills and structures that make you different, you get the best of both worlds. A sharper organization that still knows how to think, decide, and act like humans when it matters most.
The skills and relationships you are about to offload to AI are the same ones your competitors have never been able to copy. Once you let those atrophy, no model upgrade is going to give them back to you.
See you next week.
Whenever You’re Ready, Here are 4 Ways I Can Help You:
-
Unlocking Hidden Potential – Reconnecting with Past Clients for Explosive Growth – Check out my free eBook on how you can find hidden gems in your past clients and help you crush your sales goals.
-
AI for Business Development – Download our free eBook on how you can effectively leverage AI prompts to your advantage. From properly setting up your preferred AI tool, to how to shape your prompts, save time, and get the outputs you are looking for.
-
Sales Resources at Your Fingertips – From tools, tips, demos, and how-tos, check out our Pages and content that can provide you with additional support, whether it be social selling, account management, or something else.
-
Cribworks Advisor Program – Want more than just resources? Reach out to me and see if our Advisor Program can help you scale your business.
